The Gibbs rule

Published by a ÑÇÖÞÉ«ÇéÍø Restructuring & Insolvency expert
Practice notes

The Gibbs rule

Published by a ÑÇÖÞÉ«ÇéÍø Restructuring & Insolvency expert

Practice notes
imgtext

The Gibbs rule provides that the discharge of a debt may only properly be determined by the governing law of the debt. Subject to the modifying effect of legal instruments in the area of cross-border insolvency, an English court may apply this common law rule to hold that a foreign restructuring, which purports to discharge an English law governed debt (or a debt governed by a law other than the law of the foreign restructuring), does not in fact do so in England. Consequently, the court may allow a dissenting creditor to enforce the debt in England. The nature and extent of the Gibbs rule will therefore be of interest to distressed debt investors and their advisers and this note sets out some of the important issues to be considered.

The development of the Gibbs rule

The Gibbs rule was identified and developed in a series of cases in the 19th century, beginning with Smith v Buchanan (1800) 1 East 6 (not reported by Lexis+® UK), where Lord Kenyon CJ stated:

‘[I]t is impossible to say that a contract made in one

Powered by Lexis+®
Jurisdiction(s):
United Kingdom
Key definition:
Governing Law definition
What does Governing Law mean?

Governing law is the law stipulated in a contract to determine a dispute. Where there is no valid governing law clause, the law to be applied, the applicable law, will be determined in accordance with the relevant regulation, convention, legislation or common law rules.

Popular documents